The Formula Stocked Shelves It Could Not Save
A proprietary inventory system grew a retailer to more than $4 billion in annual revenue. The company filed for bankruptcy in 2011.
The Space Is Larger Than It Should Be
The storefront is a fitness studio now, or a discount furniture outlet, or nothing at all. You can still see where the sign hung.
The space was enormous for a retail store. Nearly twenty-five thousand square feet on average, wider than a grocery store and deeper than most departments.
You used to spend an hour there on a Saturday and leave with a bag heavier than you expected. The shelves ran floor to ceiling, organized by hand-lettered category signs.
A music section had listening stations. A cafe sat near the back.
Someone was always reading in an armchair who looked like they had been there since morning.
The store was Borders.
Got $300? Position in This Ticker Before October 28
You could have the chance to make big gains from the Federal Reserve’s next move…
But if you wait until its October 28 announcement, you could miss it.
Click here to see the ticker I'm watching, because the money may start moving before Warsh announces their decision.
He’s just raised rates for the first time in more than three years…
The Fed has already signaled another hike could be on the way…
Which means you have a brief window of opportunity to get positioned in one ticker I know very well.
In fact, with this ticker, even a small movement in it can more than double your money.
For example, in January 2022, as the Fed prepared to raise rates, this ticker moved just 4%.
But readers who followed my trade had the chance to make 117% in under a month.
If I’m right, the setup that’s forming could be even bigger this time around.
And you can get started with as little as $300.
I give away the name of the ticker in my short briefing.
The Product Was the System, Not the Shelf
Tom and Louis Borders opened an 800-square-foot used bookstore in Ann Arbor, Michigan, in 1971. Both were alumni of the University of Michigan.
The store was tiny. The insight behind it was not.
Louis Borders built a computerized inventory system that tracked which titles sold in which locations and predicted what to reorder. In the 1970s, most bookstores stocked shelves by instinct.
A buyer visited a store, eyeballed the gaps, and placed an order. Borders replaced that guesswork with software.
The system told each location what to carry based on what its specific neighborhood was actually buying. By 1976, the brothers had spun the technology into a separate company called Book Inventory Systems. It supplied purchasing data, centralized ordering, and twice-weekly shipments to independent bookstores across the Midwest.
The retail store in Ann Arbor was one expression of that engine. The engine itself was the real product.
A bookstore that knew what its neighborhood would buy before the customer walked in could stock 150,000 titles and turn a profit on nearly every one. That was the advantage nobody saw from the armchair by the cafe.
Fifty-Two New Stores in a Single Year
Kmart acquired Borders in 1992 for roughly $125 million and merged it with Waldenbooks, a chain of mall-based bookstores it had owned since 1984. The combined operation went public as Borders Group in 1995.
The inventory system powered the expansion. Between January 1998 and January 1999, the company opened 52 superstores, the largest single-year expansion in its history.
By 2003, Borders Group operated 1,249 stores under the Borders and Waldenbooks names. It was the second-largest bookstore chain in the country.
By 2005, the company reported more than $4 billion in annual revenue and posted its last profit: $101 million.
The Screen Replaced the Shelf
In 2001, rather than continue running its own digital storefront, Borders outsourced its entire online operation to Amazon. Amazon became the merchant of record. It handled the inventory, the fulfillment, the customer service, and the data.
For seven years, every online buyer who thought they were shopping at Borders was building Amazon's recommendation engine instead.
Borders ended the arrangement in 2008 and launched its own website. By then the company was half a decade behind in the digital market it once could have led.
Meanwhile, the sorting advantage that had once separated Borders from every other bookstore had quietly become the industry standard. Barnes and Noble built its own online store. Publishers improved their own distribution.
The algorithm that made Borders extraordinary in the 1980s was ordinary everywhere by the 2000s.
All the Armchairs Went at Once
Revenue fell every year after 2006. The company lost $157 million in 2007 alone.
Its workforce shrank from roughly 36,000 to 19,500.
On February 16, 2011, Borders Group filed for bankruptcy. It closed 226 stores immediately and began searching for a buyer.
None appeared. By September 18, every remaining location had been liquidated.
Barnes and Noble purchased the trademark and the customer list. The armchairs were hauled away.
The Recommendation Engine Has No Aisles
The logic Louis Borders built in the 1970s was simple: track what sells, predict what will sell next, stock accordingly.
Every streaming service, every online retailer, every digital storefront now runs a version of that same idea.
The bookstore that pioneered it could not survive the move from shelf to screen.
The aisles went quiet.
The sorting found new shelves.
